• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Injurix

From auto accident to slips, trips and falls, learn about all kinds of personal injury law and important legal matters

From auto accident to slips, trips and falls, learn about all kinds of personal injury law and important legal matters

  • Motor Vehicle Accidents
    • Car Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Truck Accidents
    • Bike & Pedestrian Accidents
  • Personal Injury
    • Slip and Falls
    • Wrongful Death
    • Bad Faith Insurance
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Workers’ Compensation
  • Hurt at Work
  • About Us
  • Write for Us
Home / Insurance Bad Faith / State Court Protects Policyholders On Texas Insurance Code 542

State Court Protects Policyholders On Texas Insurance Code 542

October 28, 2019

Texas insurance code 542

For the past 15 years, Texas-based insurance companies have used the appraisal process to delay payment of reasonable claims. A decision by the state Supreme Court in July 2019 set the trajectory back in favor of policyholders by upholding the original intent of Texas insurance code 542.

The Prompt Payment of Insurance Claims Act has a part of it—Section 542—that requires insurance companies to respond to claims and pay them in a reasonable manner, setting up deadlines along the way.

But there was a loophole.

If insurers began the appraisal process, even on non-controversial claims, they could draw out the process on unsuspecting businesses and consumers. As long as the claim was eventually paid, legal obligations were considered satisfied.

Insurers were emboldened by the Breshears vs. State Farm Lloyds 2004 court ruling that said as long as a claim was eventually paid, there could be no violation of Prompt Payment requirements. The ruling allowed insurance companies to do what one lawyer called “weaponize the appraisal process”.

The most recent decision moved the pendulum back in the other direction.

Barbara Tech is a San Antonio-based company that suffered weather-related damage in 2013. They filed a claim and State Farm refused to pay, estimating damages at $3,153 and the company had a $5,000 deductible.

The appraisal process began and damages came in somewhat higher than the deductible—$195,345.63, to be exact. State Farm paid the claim.

But Barbara Tech didn’t drop their legal action.

They charged that State Farm had failed to meet payment deadlines. The insurer fell back on the appraisal process loophole. This time, it didn’t work.

The Texas Supreme Court ruled that code 542 is not an invitation to delay payment and that eventual payment of claims is not prima facie (accepted as correct until proven otherwise) evidence of compliance, as courts had previously interpreted. It wasn’t the final word on Barbara Tech’s case, but it eliminated the loophole that had been abused.

Read more about insurance bad faith.

Filed Under: Insurance Bad Faith Tagged With: insurance

Primary Sidebar

Categories

  • Car Accidents
  • Insurance Bad Faith
  • Medical Malpractice
  • Motorcycle Accidents
  • Pedestrian & Bicycle Accidents
  • Slip & Falls
  • Truck Accidents
  • Workers’ Compensation
  • Wrongful Death

Law Firm Resources

  • Injury Lawyer Directory
  • Law firm SEO

Accident Victim Resources

  • Finding Accident Lawyer for Your Case
  • Post-Accident Journal
  • Personal Injury Calculator

Pain Management Products

  • Organic CBD Oil
  • CBD Oil for Pets

Law Blogs

  • Lawteryx
  • RedLawList.com

© 2021 Injurix. All Rights reserved.

About Us  •  Write for Us